Buttermilk in Coffee: It’s Not a Joke!

The Best Answer:

Buttermilk is a trendy type of milk to combine with coffee, despite what you might think. It has characteristics of subtle sweetness and makes all coffee drinks super creamy. And the best part is that you can use it to make tons of other recipes, from desserts to smoothies and dressings!

Many people are surprised to learn that buttermilk is a staple in some parts of the world. It’s an ingredient in many delicious recipes! But, maybe you’re thinking, “buttermilk is just for biscuits and gravy!”

However, this traditional American breakfast food can be used as an ingredient or even a substitute for dairy milk. So if you’ve ever thought about trying out some new coffee drinks with unique ingredients like buttermilk, keep on reading!

Buttermilk in Coffee

Buttermilk in Coffee

“I know, I know. You’re thinking, “Buttermilk in coffee? That’s not right.” But hear me out. First of all, we’re talking about a drink that is already well-known for its rich creaminess and sweetness. And second, buttermilk has been used in food to add flavor for centuries.

Coffee and buttermilk are two ingredients that probably wouldn’t come to mind when you think of a typical combination. However, they go together surprisingly well, as many coffee shops have found out the hard way!

Coffee and buttermilk might seem like an odd pair, but if you’re willing to give it a try, there’s no reason why they shouldn’t be enjoyed together. We’ve got some ideas on how you can start enjoying this unusual pairing!

But first, let’s talk about what buttermilk is!

What is Buttermilk?

Buttermilk is the thin liquid leftover from making butter, and it’s a great ingredient to add to coffee. Making buttermilk is to make butter out of cream, and then buttermilk is left over. The liquid itself has a great taste that’s slightly sour with hints of sweetness. Buttermilk is very common in baking because it helps the cake rise better than regular milk, so adding some into your coffee isn’t necessarily unheard of!

What are some benefits of buttermilk?

There are plenty of good things about buttermilk being put into coffee. For one thing, you’re getting calcium from the dairy product, which can help prevent osteoporosis and contribute to muscle strength. Additionally, there aren’t any carbs or sugars added since it comes straight from milk already sweetened by lactose. But, of course, if you have lactose intolerance, this may not be the best idea!

Buttermilk is great to add to your morning cup because it doesn’t have any carbs or sugars and has a ton of calcium that’s good for you. It also adds creaminess, which might make up for not having milk in your brew, contributing to its delicious taste.

Buttermilk lasts longer than fresh whole milk, so it’s an excellent option for those who have trouble using up milk before the expiration date. Buttermilk also adds a creamy texture and extra flavor to baked goods, salads dressings, and casseroles.

How to Use Buttermilk

using buttermilk

Buttermilk can be used for many different things in the kitchen. It is suitable as a drink or on pancakes because of its taste and great cooking! You can use it instead of water, for example, if you want fluffier baked goods which will stay fluffier longer than without using any liquid at all. Buttermilk makes your biscuits rise better and adds moisture, so they don’t dry out quickly during baking or while waiting around after coming out of the oven.

Here are some of my favorite ways to use buttermilk:

Use buttermilk in beverages.

You can make many drinks by replacing regular milk with buttermilk:

– First and foremost, you can replace regular milk with buttermilk for all your favorite coffee drinks! From cappuccinos and mochas to iced lattes and cold brews, buttermilk is a brilliant addition to your coffee, and it won’t only make it creamy but also add some sweet flavor notes to it!

– Smoothies are a great way to incorporate buttermilk into your diet. Just mix banana, yogurt, and buttermilk for one of the most delicious smoothie recipes you can make!

– Buttermilk is also a fantastic ingredient for bubble teas and other types of milky teas like chai lattes!

– Whip up protein shakes using buttermilk. The protein shake recipes are endless, so experiment to find what works best for you!

Other uses for buttermilk

-Add it into pancake or waffle batter for a richer taste.

-Make ranch dressing by adding chopped herbs like chives, dill, thyme with salt & pepper instead of the mayo in your favorite recipe! Just add milk until you get desired consistency.

-Mix it with shredded cheese along with dried spices such as paprika, garlic powder, and onion powder before baking on top of potatoes for an instant cheesy crust without any fuss! Or make a healthier version using breadcrumbs instead of cheese.

-Use it in mashed potatoes, potato salad, or even mac & cheese to add richness and flavor without making them too heavy with cream!

-Use it in cakes, cupcakes, and even donuts instead of milk to add a subtle tang.

-Add some buttermilk into your meatloaf mixture for an extra moist texture! Or make fried chicken or baked fish nuggets

-It can even be used as a marinade for fried chicken or shrimp

Buttermilk Cinnamon Latte Recipe

And here is one of my secret buttermilk coffee recipes that’s incredibly yummy during the fall and wintertime: my buttermilk cinnamon latte!



Cinnamon Sticks

One cup of regular coffee


  • Pour a cup of coffee into your mug and stir in ½ tablespoon each of cinnamon sticks and buttermilk – this is where the real work comes in – you have to let it sit for about an hour before drinking so that the flavors can mellow out together.
  • After the hour passes, you’ll want to heat these after stirring them together and serve immediately once heated through. This should be more than enough to fill one mug. I promise you it will taste delicious!

The cinnamon sticks will give it that extra kick of spice and sweetness. Buttermilk is relatively mild, so don’t worry about the flavor being too overbearing since it mellowed out with coffee – but if you taste this after letting steep for an hour or two (or overnight) and find your mixture isn’t sweet at all – no problem! Just add more sugar on top instead.

This recipe also works well with honey as a replacement for both sugars. And if caffeine’s not your thing try using decaffeinated coffee instead of regular; then you’ll be able to enjoy these any time of day without worrying about keeping up with your quota! You can even experiment with adding different spices – like nutmeg, allspice or even cloves – whatever you feel will pair well.

Frequently Asked Questions


Can you make a buttermilk coffee cake?

Buttermilk is a dairy product made by fermenting regular whole milk with buttermilk bacteria. The resulting liquid has less fat and more acid than a traditional cream, which gives it an unusual flavor and thick consistency. This makes it perfect for baking cakes or bread that must be perfectly moist without containing too much oil.

So yes, you can use buttermilk to make a coffee cake!

What can you put in coffee instead of milk?

First, you could try a different kind of milk. Almond and coconut milk are becoming more common, but they can be expensive. These other kinds of milk might also contain some sugars that aren’t great for your health. If you don’t want to switch from dairy, there is still hope!

You could add a tablespoon or two of cream instead of half and half to get the creamy texture without all the fat and calories found in regular coffee creamer options. This will make it much better for your waistline as well as taste pretty good too! Another option would be using flavored syrups like vanilla or hazelnut syrup into your drink with either an equal amount or slightly less than what you would typically use of milk.

This will give you a nice subtle flavor without adding sugar or fat to your drink! Sweetening syrups are also available at the grocery store, which can be added in moderation for sweetness if that’s what you prefer. If none of these suggestions sounds reasonable, there are always artificial sweeteners on the market today that are calorie-free and would probably taste better than some other options too!

Ultimately, it all comes down to personal preference, how much dairy is tolerable for each person, and their health goals and preferences with food choices.

Last Thoughts

All in all, I think it’s safe to say that adding buttermilk to your coffee is a good idea. It’s light and refreshing with just enough flavor to take your brew to the next level! Plus, it has so many other uses as well!

This article reminds us that while some things may seem like jokes, they can be the best ideas. Be open to new ways of thinking, and you may find yourself on an unexpected journey filled with innovation. What are your thoughts? Let us know!

Related Articles